Drafting Caleb Williams while keeping Justin Fields would be an ill-advised move for the Bears.
Could the Bears potentially draft quarterback Caleb Williams with the No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft and still retain Justin Fields on the roster? Although it may seem highly unlikely, NFL insider Adam Schefter has hinted that the team has at least entertained the idea.
Schefter mentioned on ESPN that this possibility has been a topic of discussion within the Bears organization. However, it's essential to recognize that as we approach the heart of the NFL's "lying season," where teams and agents strategically leak information for their own purposes, such statements should be taken with a grain of salt. It's plausible that the Bears could be using this information to drive up interest in a potential trade for Fields.
Despite the skepticism, Schefter emphasized that this isn't merely a smokescreen; the Bears have genuinely deliberated on the matter. While exploring scenarios like keeping both Fields and Williams is part of the pre-draft process, actual implementation is a different matter altogether.
Considering recent examples where young quarterbacks benefited from learning on the sidelines, like Patrick Mahomes behind Alex Smith and Jordan Love behind Aaron Rodgers, it's understandable why the Bears might consider this option. However, the discrepancy in experience between Fields and his mentors raises doubts about the effectiveness of such a setup. Additionally, with the Bears needing to decide on Fields' fifth-year option soon, keeping him as a backup seems impractical, especially with Tyson Bagent proving himself as a reliable backup and developmental quarterback.
Moreover, introducing a potential controversy between Williams and Fields could be detrimental to the team's stability and future prospects. If Williams were to struggle as a starter, there would likely be clamors for Fields to reclaim the position, and vice versa. This situation could diminish Fields' value as a future starter if he were to struggle or be relegated to a backup role.
Ultimately, while it's conceivable that the Bears have discussed the possibility of retaining both Williams and Fields, it remains uncertain whether they will deem it the best course of action moving forward.
| POLL | ||
12 FEVRIER | 1 ANSWERS Drafting Caleb Williams while keeping Justin Fields would be an ill-advised move for the Bears. Should the Bears draft Caleb Williams? | ||
| yes | 0 | 0 % |
| No | 0 | 0 % |
| List of polls | ||
