Although Cincinnati and Los Angeles may face difficulties paying their franchise quarterbacks, there's no doubt that Burrow and Herbert are worth lucrative deals. Hurts is also on track for a significant pay raise, having impressed the Eagles' front office. However, Tagovailoa suffered two concussions in 2022 and ended the season on injured reserve, casting doubt on his long-term future with the Dolphins. While Miami can exercise Tagovailoa's fifth-year option to keep him on the team through 2024, it remains unclear whether the Dolphins will offer him a long-term deal.
Miami's head coach Mike McDaniel said that the Dolphins and Tagovailoa both want him to play at a high level for a long time in Miami. The team's general manager Chris Grier said that all options are on the table and that they are not in a rush to make any decisions. Grier also admitted that Tagovailoa's health will play a role in any potential extension, but that they are not afraid to make a long-term commitment to him.
Despite the Dolphins' enthusiasm for Tagovailoa's future, they are not as committed to him as the Bengals, Chargers, and Eagles are to their quarterbacks. Duke Tobin, a Bengals executive, stated that Burrow's contract will get done when it gets done. Jeffrey Lurie, the Eagles' owner, said that Hurts has nothing to prove to earn long-term job security. In contrast, the Dolphins are taking a more cautious approach with Tagovailoa.
While Grier is not afraid to think long term with Tagovailoa's contract, it does not mean that Miami will make a tangible offer this offseason. The Dolphins will likely exercise Tagovailoa's fifth-year option to avoid a situation similar to the Giants' with Daniel Jones. However, Tagovailoa will need to return to the field, stay healthy, and meet expectations in 2023 to earn a long-term deal with Miami. Until then, Tagovailoa will likely be motivated to prove that he can be a sustainable option for the Dolphins.